Skip to content
  • +91 990363 5533 (Kolkata)
  • Kolkata@clatapult.com
Search
Close
clatapult logo
  • Home
    • CLATapult Bhubaneswar
    • CLATapult Nagpur
    • CLATapult Amravati
    • CLATapult Asansol
  • Law Schools
    • NLSIU, Bangalore
    • NALSAR, Hyderabad
    • NUJS, Kolkata
    • NLU, Delhi
    • NLU, Jodhpur
    • GNLU, Gujarat
    • NLIU, Bhopal
    • Symbiosis Law School, Pune
    • HNLU, Raipur
    • RMLNLU, Lucknow
    • RGNUL, Patiala
    • National Law University, Odisha
  • About Us
    • TEAM
    • FACULTY
    • CONTENT
    • MEDIA
    • Why CLATapult
      • CLATapult’s Testimonials
      • Topper’s Interview : West Bengal Rank 1 in CLAT 2017
      • Topper’s Interview: AIR 9 & WB Rank 1
  • Courses
    • 1 Year Course, Class-Action
    • 2 year Course, Counsel
    • NLSAT 2022
    • Marathon for CLAT LLM/PG
    • CLATapult’s Relay Program (LL.M)
    • CLATapult’s Marathon Program (LL.M)
    • CLATapult Bluebook Plus (2 Years) – For Class XIth Students
    • CLATapult Bluebook (Correspondence Course/Distance Learning)
    • CLATapult Probe (Test Series)
    • CLAT LLM
    • Postal/Correspondence Course
    • CLAT Online Classes
  • Archive
    • CLAT Tips
    • CLAT, CLATapult & Law Schools
    • Legal Reasoning
    • Logical Reasoning
    • Static General Knowledge
    • Current Affairs
    • English
    • Maths
    • The Furious Five
      • Legal ‘Mantis’ Reasoning
      • General ‘Viper’ Knowledge
      • Tigress : Kung Fu :: Aspirant : Logical Reasoning
      • Monkey-ish English
      • Mathematics, the Crane Way
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
    • North Kolkata Center
    • South Kolkata Center
    • CLAT Coaching in Bhubaneswar
Menu
  • Home
    • CLATapult Bhubaneswar
    • CLATapult Nagpur
    • CLATapult Amravati
    • CLATapult Asansol
  • Law Schools
    • NLSIU, Bangalore
    • NALSAR, Hyderabad
    • NUJS, Kolkata
    • NLU, Delhi
    • NLU, Jodhpur
    • GNLU, Gujarat
    • NLIU, Bhopal
    • Symbiosis Law School, Pune
    • HNLU, Raipur
    • RMLNLU, Lucknow
    • RGNUL, Patiala
    • National Law University, Odisha
  • About Us
    • TEAM
    • FACULTY
    • CONTENT
    • MEDIA
    • Why CLATapult
      • CLATapult’s Testimonials
      • Topper’s Interview : West Bengal Rank 1 in CLAT 2017
      • Topper’s Interview: AIR 9 & WB Rank 1
  • Courses
    • 1 Year Course, Class-Action
    • 2 year Course, Counsel
    • NLSAT 2022
    • Marathon for CLAT LLM/PG
    • CLATapult’s Relay Program (LL.M)
    • CLATapult’s Marathon Program (LL.M)
    • CLATapult Bluebook Plus (2 Years) – For Class XIth Students
    • CLATapult Bluebook (Correspondence Course/Distance Learning)
    • CLATapult Probe (Test Series)
    • CLAT LLM
    • Postal/Correspondence Course
    • CLAT Online Classes
  • Archive
    • CLAT Tips
    • CLAT, CLATapult & Law Schools
    • Legal Reasoning
    • Logical Reasoning
    • Static General Knowledge
    • Current Affairs
    • English
    • Maths
    • The Furious Five
      • Legal ‘Mantis’ Reasoning
      • General ‘Viper’ Knowledge
      • Tigress : Kung Fu :: Aspirant : Logical Reasoning
      • Monkey-ish English
      • Mathematics, the Crane Way
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
    • North Kolkata Center
    • South Kolkata Center
    • CLAT Coaching in Bhubaneswar
LOGIN

CLAT Legal Reasoning: Statutory Authority

  • Home
  • Blog
  • CLAT Legal Reasoning: Statutory Authority
  • By CLATapult
  • March 8, 2017
  • 9:00 am
clat legal reasoning statutory authority

by Krishna Pallavi

Firstly, let us understand what the terms ‘Statutory’ and ‘Authority’ separately mean. The word Statutory means anything which is required, permitted or enacted by a statute or legislature. The word Authority means the power or right to give order, make decisions and enforce obedience. Now, Statutory and Authority clubbed together mean, the right or the power given by the a statute, which permits certain acts. However, this power of the legislature to permit certain acts should not be against the welfare of the people.

Statutory Authority is considered as a defence in tort. Any damage resulting from an act, which if authorised by the legislature to be done, is not actionable even though in normal circumstances it would be a tort. In simple words, an injury or damage caused by a person is authorised by the legislature, then he/she can escape liability. However, if the statute itself provides for some compensation for the said act, then the injured party can claim such compensation.

 

To understand this, let us consider the following example:

A builds a cottage away from the city in order to live a peaceful and a noise-free life. However, after few months from A moving into his new cottage, the railway authorities with the orders from the government start constructing a railway line beside A’s house. After, the construction was complete, the trains start to pass through the line on a regular basis. This caused huge inconvenience to A, as there were constant trains moving to and fro, vibrations, smoke and emissions from the train.

A files a suit against the railway authorities on private nuisance. Will A’s claim stand? No. Why? The act to construct a railway line beside A’s house was an act authorised by the government. However, if the law states, that A could receive any compensation for this act, then A will be entitled to receive such compensation.

If the authorities who are doing a said act under the Statutory Authority are negligent, then they cannot claim the defence of the same.

To understand this, let us consider the above example with a little twist in it:

A builds a cottage away from the city in order to live a peaceful and a noise-free life. However, after few months from A moving into his new cottage, the railway authorities with the orders from the government start constructing a railway line beside A’s house. While constructing the railway line, one day a railway servant left trimmings of grass and hedges near the railway line. He was warned several times to not do it.

The next day, during the trial of the trains on the new railway track, the sparks from the engine set fire to the grass and hedges near the railway line. The sparks were carried to the plaintiff’s cottage, and burnt the cottage down.

In such circumstances, the railways authorities could claim, that such action of theirs was supported by law. Will their claim stand? No. Why? Unlike the situation above, in the present situation, the railway authorities though authorised by law to do certain acts, were negligent which is not excusable.

Therefore, they can be held liable for the present act.

The Authority given by the statute is of two types

Absolute Authority and Conditional Authority. In the former’s case even though nuisance or necessary harm is inflicted through an act, the legislature provides them absolute power and therefore, the authorities cannot be held liable. In the latter’s case, the act authorized can be done provided the same is possible without causing nuisance or some other harm.

Such conditions imposed by the statute can either be expressed or implied.

To understand this, let us consider the following example:

A hospital authority wanted to eradicate smallpox. To do the same, they erected a hospital in a residential area. This created a danger of spread of infection to the people residing in and around the hospital. The court issued the an injunction (an order to stop a continuing activity) against the hospital.

The hospital authorities took the plea, that they were granted authority by a statute to do the act. The court held that, in the present case there was a conditional authority that was vested in the hospital authorities. It was further stated that no statute can grant such action to a person or a body to do an act against the welfare of the people.

Therefore, in this case the hospital authorities were held liable

Note: The railway acts are generally given an Absolute Authority by the statute whether any nuisance is caused by it or not.

CLATapult Courses

Crash Course for CLAT 2022 (March 21 to CLAT 2022)

₹24,999.00
Check Details

2 year Course, Counsel (for December 2022 CLAT)

₹69,500.00
Check Details

1-Year Course, Class Action (for CLAT 2022)

₹24,000.00
Check Details

Writing NLSAT 2022

₹31,999.00
Check Details
All Courses
  • CLAT, CLAT 2017, clat legal aptitude, clat legal reasoning, general defences, law of torts
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Telegram

admin

All Posts »
PrevPreviousCLAT Maths: Solved Questions of Permutation and Combination
NextCLAT Tips: Quora Quotes – on Latin Phrases + Grammar vs. Wren & MartinNext

Related Posts

Topper in LSAT 2021 – Nandini Tripathi [479 out of 480] 1-Year student in CLATapult

Nandini Tripathi, a 1-Year student in CLATapult for the 2020-21 sessions, got a score of 479 out of 480 and became a Topper in LSAT

Read More »
June 20, 2021

Achiever 101: Interview of Yashaswini Santuka (AIR 101, Odisha Rank 1, CLAT 2019)

Yashaswini Santuka was a 2 year (Counsel) student at CLATapult. She secured an All India Rank of 101 and Odisha Rank 1 in CLAT 2019.

Read More »
July 8, 2019

Achiever 101: Interview of Tushar Krishna (AIR 208, CLAT 2019; AIR 134, AILET 2019)

Tushar Krishna was a 1 year (Class-action) student at CLATapult. He secured an All India Rank of 208 in CLAT 2019 and All India Rank

Read More »
July 1, 2019

Achiever 101: Interview of Athira Johny (AIR 32, AILET 2019)

Athira Johny was a 1 year (Class-action) student at CLATapult. She secured an All India Rank of 32 in AILET 2019.   Congratulations on your

Read More »
June 28, 2019

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • CLATegize
  • 2 Year Course (Counsel)
  • 1 Year Course (Class-Action)
  • CLAT Tips
  • Legal Reasoning
  • Logical Resoning
  • Static General Knowledge
  • Current Affairs
  • English
  • Maths
  • Why CLATapult
  • Classroom Courses
  • Online Courses
  • About CLATapult
  • Team CLATapult
  • Faculty
  • Law Schools
  • CLATapult in Kolkata (Salt Lake Center)
  • CLATapult in Kolkata (Ultadanga Center)
  • CLATapult in Nagpur
  • CLATapult in Bhubaneswar
  • CLATapult in Amravati
  • CLATapult in Asansol

We Are Here To Help You

contact us today

  • Refund and Returns Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Refund and Returns Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

CLATapult Education LLP © 2022 All Rights Reserved

Site by WordPress Expert in India

  • CALL US NOW