Skip to content
  • +91 990363 5533 (Kolkata)
  • Kolkata@clatapult.com
Search
Close
clatapult logo
  • Home
    • CLATapult Bhubaneswar
    • CLATapult Nagpur
    • CLATapult Amravati
    • CLATapult Asansol
  • Law Schools
    • NLSIU, Bangalore
    • NALSAR, Hyderabad
    • NUJS, Kolkata
    • NLU, Delhi
    • NLU, Jodhpur
    • GNLU, Gujarat
    • NLIU, Bhopal
    • Symbiosis Law School, Pune
    • HNLU, Raipur
    • RMLNLU, Lucknow
    • RGNUL, Patiala
    • National Law University, Odisha
  • About Us
    • TEAM
    • FACULTY
    • CONTENT
    • MEDIA
    • Why CLATapult
      • CLATapult’s Testimonials
      • Topper’s Interview : West Bengal Rank 1 in CLAT 2017
      • Topper’s Interview: AIR 9 & WB Rank 1
  • Courses
    • 1 Year Course, Class-Action
    • 2 year Course, Counsel
    • NLSAT 2022
    • Marathon for CLAT LLM/PG
    • CLATapult’s Relay Program (LL.M)
    • CLATapult’s Marathon Program (LL.M)
    • CLATapult Bluebook Plus (2 Years) – For Class XIth Students
    • CLATapult Bluebook (Correspondence Course/Distance Learning)
    • CLATapult Probe (Test Series)
    • CLAT LLM
    • Postal/Correspondence Course
    • CLAT Online Classes
  • Archive
    • CLAT Tips
    • CLAT, CLATapult & Law Schools
    • Legal Reasoning
    • Logical Reasoning
    • Static General Knowledge
    • Current Affairs
    • English
    • Maths
    • The Furious Five
      • Legal ‘Mantis’ Reasoning
      • General ‘Viper’ Knowledge
      • Tigress : Kung Fu :: Aspirant : Logical Reasoning
      • Monkey-ish English
      • Mathematics, the Crane Way
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
    • North Kolkata Center
    • South Kolkata Center
    • CLAT Coaching in Bhubaneswar
Menu
  • Home
    • CLATapult Bhubaneswar
    • CLATapult Nagpur
    • CLATapult Amravati
    • CLATapult Asansol
  • Law Schools
    • NLSIU, Bangalore
    • NALSAR, Hyderabad
    • NUJS, Kolkata
    • NLU, Delhi
    • NLU, Jodhpur
    • GNLU, Gujarat
    • NLIU, Bhopal
    • Symbiosis Law School, Pune
    • HNLU, Raipur
    • RMLNLU, Lucknow
    • RGNUL, Patiala
    • National Law University, Odisha
  • About Us
    • TEAM
    • FACULTY
    • CONTENT
    • MEDIA
    • Why CLATapult
      • CLATapult’s Testimonials
      • Topper’s Interview : West Bengal Rank 1 in CLAT 2017
      • Topper’s Interview: AIR 9 & WB Rank 1
  • Courses
    • 1 Year Course, Class-Action
    • 2 year Course, Counsel
    • NLSAT 2022
    • Marathon for CLAT LLM/PG
    • CLATapult’s Relay Program (LL.M)
    • CLATapult’s Marathon Program (LL.M)
    • CLATapult Bluebook Plus (2 Years) – For Class XIth Students
    • CLATapult Bluebook (Correspondence Course/Distance Learning)
    • CLATapult Probe (Test Series)
    • CLAT LLM
    • Postal/Correspondence Course
    • CLAT Online Classes
  • Archive
    • CLAT Tips
    • CLAT, CLATapult & Law Schools
    • Legal Reasoning
    • Logical Reasoning
    • Static General Knowledge
    • Current Affairs
    • English
    • Maths
    • The Furious Five
      • Legal ‘Mantis’ Reasoning
      • General ‘Viper’ Knowledge
      • Tigress : Kung Fu :: Aspirant : Logical Reasoning
      • Monkey-ish English
      • Mathematics, the Crane Way
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
    • North Kolkata Center
    • South Kolkata Center
    • CLAT Coaching in Bhubaneswar
LOGIN

CLAT Legal Reasoning: Agreement vs. Contract

  • Home
  • Blog
  • CLAT Legal Reasoning: Agreement vs. Contract
  • By CLATapult
  • February 24, 2017
  • 9:28 am
clat law of contracts introduction

By Siddharth Dey

In the previous article, we were discussing how a contract is formed. We saw that it starts out with a proposal and a promise, which are supported by a consideration. Together, these make up an agreement.

We noted that an agreement, despite looking almost similar to the naked eye, is quite different from a contract.

Sections 2(g) and 2(h) of the Indian Contract Act, 1872 not only give us valuable information on the law regarding agreements, but also the foundation of the difference mentioned earlier.

 Agreement & Contract

Section 2(g) says, “An agreement not enforceable by law is said to be void”.

Section 2(h) says, “An agreement enforceable by law is a contract”.

According to these two clauses, (g) & (h), Agreements can either be:

1. Enforceable by law, or;

2. Void;

Only those agreements which are enforceable by law are called contracts.

Effectively,
law of contracts introduction

Thus, all contracts are agreements; but not all agreements are contracts. Some of them are ‘void’.

 What is ‘enforceable by law’ and what is ‘void’?

When you approach the court to seek an order making the other party to the contract fulfill its obligations, it is said that you are enforcing the contract. Enforcement by an authority means to compel a person under its authority to do a certain thing.

It goes without saying that the courts can only enforce what is in accordance with the law or is permitted by the law, even when it comes to Contracts. The Indian Contract Act is the law which will normally apply in such a case.

As already said above, agreements which are not enforceable by law will be void.

Why are such agreements not enforceable by law?

This is because the term ‘agreement’ has a very ordinary usage, i.e., every Tom, Dick, and Harry enters into an agreement, every second of every minute. Therefore, if the Act allowed all of them to be enforceable by the courts, then even the most trivial of matters would have to be decided upon by the Courts!

The word ‘void’ in this context means ‘void ab initio’ or “void from the beginning”. Under the Indian Contract Act, this means that the such an agreement was void or invalid under the Act, from the very moment it was formed.

Void agreements are not necessarily illegal. Such agreements are simply unfit to be recognized as ‘contracts’ under the Act.

You will notice that agreements which are not enforceable by law do not cease to be enforceable in other ways – when your mother asked you to finish homework, you’d either do that or risk the consequences!

Since the Act only deals with contracts, it is neither concerned with such agreements or the ways in which they can be enforced.

So, what makes some agreements void, and others, contracts?

 Legal validity or legal intention of the parties

This can be taken straight from the definition of a contract under Section 2 (h) – agreements which can be enforceable by law (contracts) are legally valid. Why? That’s because, logically speaking, a court cannot enforce something which has no legal validity! Those two go hand in hand.

Additionally, an agreement which a court cannot enforce is void.

To understand why such a distinction is made, let’s take an example. If you and your friend decide to go to a movie, you buy two tickets, and your friend doesn’t show up, that’s an agreement which is not legally valid.

agreement contract
Contracts vs. Agreements

 

“Why so?”

It might seem obvious already, but firstly, the court will not bother itself with something as trivial & harmless as this (as already said before). This follows the general principle of law “de minimis non curat lex” which means that the “law does not concern itself with trifles”.

Secondly, in no way did your friend have in mind that you will drag him to court over this issue. The court will point out that there was an absence of what we term as the intention to create legal relations.

Since a contract has lawful or legal validity, both parties must intend or have the willingness to create legal relations between themselves – such an intention will legally bind the parties to the contract. If they do not perform it, then the court can enforce the contract against them.

Your friend would not even dream of looking inside a courtroom in this case! The contract between you and your friend maybe morally or socially binding at best, but not legally. The agreement does not cease to be void in those ways, but only legally.

However, if you are a sweets manufacturer, and place an order with the supplier for 100 kilos of sugar to be delivered on a particular date, you can enforce the agreement in the court if the sugar is not delivered by that date.

N.B. A contract can never be void ab initio. The phrase “void contract” makes little sense since contracts have to be legally enforceable from the moment they are formed, in order to be called “contracts”. That’s why, agreements which are not enforceable by law are called void agreements instead.
Contracts can, however, later become void or invalid, if it is found that certain requirements of contracts were not met, or the parties mutually decide to nullify the contract, etc.

CLATapult Courses

Crash Course for CLAT 2022 (March 21 to CLAT 2022)

₹24,999.00
Check Details

2 year Course, Counsel (for December 2022 CLAT)

₹69,500.00
Check Details

1-Year Course, Class Action (for CLAT 2022)

₹24,000.00
Check Details

Writing NLSAT 2022

₹31,999.00
Check Details
All Courses
  • CLAT, CLAT 2017, clat legal aptitude, clat legal reasoning, law of contracts
Facebook
Twitter
LinkedIn
WhatsApp
Telegram

admin

All Posts »
PrevPreviousAn enigma, that is Legal Reasoning
NextCurrent Affairs for CLAT 2017: April 2016Next

Related Posts

Topper in LSAT 2021 – Nandini Tripathi [479 out of 480] 1-Year student in CLATapult

Nandini Tripathi, a 1-Year student in CLATapult for the 2020-21 sessions, got a score of 479 out of 480 and became a Topper in LSAT

Read More »
June 20, 2021

Achiever 101: Interview of Yashaswini Santuka (AIR 101, Odisha Rank 1, CLAT 2019)

Yashaswini Santuka was a 2 year (Counsel) student at CLATapult. She secured an All India Rank of 101 and Odisha Rank 1 in CLAT 2019.

Read More »
July 8, 2019

Achiever 101: Interview of Tushar Krishna (AIR 208, CLAT 2019; AIR 134, AILET 2019)

Tushar Krishna was a 1 year (Class-action) student at CLATapult. He secured an All India Rank of 208 in CLAT 2019 and All India Rank

Read More »
July 1, 2019

Achiever 101: Interview of Athira Johny (AIR 32, AILET 2019)

Athira Johny was a 1 year (Class-action) student at CLATapult. She secured an All India Rank of 32 in AILET 2019.   Congratulations on your

Read More »
June 28, 2019

1 thought on “<b>CLAT Legal Reasoning</b>: Agreement vs. Contract”

  1. Rahul
    October 12, 2017 at 4:45 am

    thanks for sharing this article. It really good.

    Reply

Leave a Comment Cancel Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  • CLATegize
  • 2 Year Course (Counsel)
  • 1 Year Course (Class-Action)
  • CLAT Tips
  • Legal Reasoning
  • Logical Resoning
  • Static General Knowledge
  • Current Affairs
  • English
  • Maths
  • Why CLATapult
  • Classroom Courses
  • Online Courses
  • About CLATapult
  • Team CLATapult
  • Faculty
  • Law Schools
  • CLATapult in Kolkata (Salt Lake Center)
  • CLATapult in Kolkata (Ultadanga Center)
  • CLATapult in Nagpur
  • CLATapult in Bhubaneswar
  • CLATapult in Amravati
  • CLATapult in Asansol

We Are Here To Help You

contact us today

  • Refund and Returns Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use
  • Refund and Returns Policy
  • Privacy Policy
  • Terms of Use

CLATapult Education LLP © 2022 All Rights Reserved

Site by WordPress Expert in India

  • CALL US NOW